Conversation 650-009

TapeTape 650StartTuesday, January 18, 1972 at 11:31 AMEndTuesday, January 18, 1972 at 12:31 PMTape start time01:55:20Tape end time02:56:09ParticipantsNixon, Richard M. (President);  Burns, Arthur F.;  Connally, John B.;  Woods, Rose Mary;  [Unknown person(s)]Recording deviceOval Office

On January 18, 1972, President Richard M. Nixon, Arthur F. Burns, John B. Connally, Rose Mary Woods, and unknown person(s) met in the Oval Office of the White House from 11:31 am to 12:31 pm. The Oval Office taping system captured this recording, which is known as Conversation 650-009 of the White House Tapes.

Conversation No. 650-9

Date: January 18, 1972
Time: 11:31 am - 12:31 pm
Location: Oval Office

The President met with Arthur F. Burns and John B. Connally.

     General conversation
         -Weather

     Quadriad meeting
         -Schedule
               -State of the Union address
         -Herbert Stein

Rose Mary Woods entered at 11:33 am.

     Memorandum
        -The President's response to note on Chilean loan
             -Confidentiality
                                             20

                          NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                                     Tape Subject Log
                                       (rev. 10/06)



               -Reciprocity
          -Copies
               -William P. Rogers

Woods left at an unknown time before 12:31 pm.

     Economy
         -Money supply
         -Federal Reserve Board [FRB]
              -John E. Sheehan
                     -Contact with Burns
                           -Monetary policy, regulatory policy
              -Federal Open Market Committee
                     -Last meeting
                     -Dissent
                           -Basis
                     -Length of meeting
         -Discount rate
         -Prime rate

An unknown man entered at an unknown time after 11:31 pm.

     Refreshments

The unknown man left at an unknown time before 12:31 pm.

     Economy
         -Discount rate
               -Changes
         -Interest rates
               -Paul A. Volcker
               -Level
         -Discount rate
               -Level
               -Stock market
         -The President’s relationship with advisors
         -Handling of issue
               -Budget message
                     -State of the Union
                     -Spending ceiling request by President
                     -Congress
                                       21

                    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                                 Tape Subject Log
                                   (rev. 10/06)
                                                                Conv. No. 650-9 (cont.)


                     -1968 action
     -Deficits
     -Inflation
     -Interest rates
     -Budget message
           -Phrasing
                 -George P. Shultz
           -Timing
           -Burns’s possible comments
     -Budget
           -Caspar W. (“Cap”) Weinberger
                 -Controls
           -Elliot L. Richardson
           -John A. Volpe
           -George W. Romney
           -Defense
                 -Costs
     -Release of statement before budget message release
           -Publicity
           -Deficit
           -Timing
           -Need for cooperation with Congress
           -Spending ceiling
                 -Taxes
           -Publicity
                 -[First name unknown] Dale
                 -Hobart Rowen
                 -Wall Street Journal
           -Agreement in administration
                 -Connally
                 -Burns
                 -Shultz
                       -Office of Management and Budget [OMB]
                 -Council of Economic Advisors [CEA]
           -Spending ceiling
                 -Inflation
                 -Current year

Water bill
    -Muskie
    -Effect on future spending
                                         22

                     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                                 Tape Subject Log
                                   (rev. 10/06)
                                                                   Conv. No. 650-9 (cont.)


     -Returns

Pay Board
     -Price Commission
     -George H. Boldt
           -Qualities
                 -Administrative ability
           -Relationship with Burns
     -Arthur J. Goldberg
           -Possible role
           -Labor management committee
           -Work with President and James R. Mitchell on steel strike
           -Possible appointment
                 -Ability
                 -Attitude toward labor
                 -Experience
                       -Secretary of Labor
                 -Possible meeting with the President
                 -Control system
                 -Administrative ability
                       -Luther Hodges
                       -Experience
                             -Secretary of Labor
                             -United Nations [UN] ambassadorship
     -Difficulties
     -Pay increase guidelines
           -Exceptions
                 -Coal miners, aerospace workers
           -Evasion
                 -Business, small farmers
           -Circumvention
                 -Reclassification of employees
           -Farm workers
           -Previous year's salary increase
           -Boldt's chairmanship
     -Goldberg
     -Price Commission
           -C. Jackson Grayson
                 -Administrative ability
                 -Meeting with Burns
                       -Price increases
                                        23

                    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                               Tape Subject Log
                                 (rev. 10/06)
                                                         Conv. No. 650-9 (cont.)


                          -Business community
                               -Reports
                                     -Justification
                               -Risk
     -Price controls
           -Exemptions
                 -Small business retailers
                      -Impact
                 -Reporting
           -Big business firms
                 -Costs
                 -Reporting
           -Price Commission
                 -Relationship with administration
                      -Cost of Living Council [COLC]
                      -Recommendations
                            -Exemptions
                 -Donald H. Rumsfeld
                 -Burns meeting with Grayson

Controls
     -The President’s role
     -The President’s view
          -Public relations
          -Substance
          -Extent
          -Freeze
          -Major firms
                -Gross National Product [GNP]
                -Employment
          -Decontrol for small firms
     -Pay Board and Price Commission
          -Criticism
                -Big business vis-à-vis labor
     -Entrepreneurs
          -Role in economy
     -Major firms
          -General Motors [GM]
          -General Electric [GE]
          -Relationship with administration
     -Decontrol
                                         24

                     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                                Tape Subject Log
                                  (rev. 10/06)
                                                          Conv. No. 650-9 (cont.)


          -Reporting
          -Small business
                -Support for the President
     -Small businesses
          -Compared to big business
     -Timing
     -The President’s role
          -Perception

Economy
    -Political objectives
          -Jobs
          -Prices
    -Pay Board
          -Goldberg
                -Prices
    -Wage Board
    -Price Commission
    -Profit margins
          -Compared to 1938, 1966
          -Economic growth
                -Profit sharing
          -1970
          -Cost cutting
          -Pay Board
                -Price Commission
                      -November 1972
    -Pay Board
          -Boldt
                -Handling of role
                      -Difficulty
          -Aerospace industry
          -Mitchell
          -Boldt
                -Shultz
          -Shultz's view
          -Instruction for Shultz
          -Goldberg
                -Relationship with the President
                -Knowledge of labor
                      -Steel workers
                                       25

                    NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                               Tape Subject Log
                                 (rev. 10/06)
                                                                Conv. No. 650-9 (cont.)


                             -John F. Kennedy
                 -Administrative abilities
                       -UN ambassadorship
           -Requirements for job
           -Labor-Management committee
           -Joseph L. Block
           -David P. Reynolds of Reynolds Company
           -Thomas Watson
           -Stuart T. Saunders of Pennsylvania
                 -Background
                       -Virginia
           -Goldberg
                 -Politics
                 -Possible meeting with the President
                 -Career
                       -Supreme Court
                       -Secretary of Labor
                       -Ambassador to UN
                       -Gubernatorial candidacy
                       -Steelworkers' chief counsel
                       -G. Harrold Carswell
                       -Compared to unknown person
                       -[Romney?]
                 -Burns’s career
     -Camp David meeting before August 15, 1971 economic action
     -Present status
     -Perceptions of economic action
     -International monetary action
     -Trade
     -Burden sharing

Japan
     -Burns’s contact with Japanese ambassador [Nobuhiko Ushiba] and other Japanese
     -View of the President's People's Republic Of China [PRC] Policy
     -Trade and monetary problem
     -Trade
          -The President’s talks with Eisaku Sato
                -Europe
     -PRC relations
          -Meetings Between The President And Japanese officials, 1966, 1967
          -Japanese interests
                                         26

                     NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                                 Tape Subject Log
                                   (rev. 10/06)
                                                                    Conv. No. 650-9 (cont.)


                -Trade
                -Compared to US interests
                -Military
     -US relations with the PRC
          -Soviet Union

Congressional hearings
    -Economists
    -Fred R. Harris
    -Edward M. Kennedy's January 17, 1972 Press Club speech on Vietnam
          -Partisanship
    -Partisanship in 1972

State of the Union address
      -Tone

Kennedy’s Press Club speech
    -Attack on the President
    -Vietnam
          -Nguyen Van Thieu

The President's opponents
     -Attacks on the President
          -Howard Hughes loan to F. Donald Nixon
          -Harris
          -Oil
                 -Harris
                      -Hughes
                 -Hubert H. Humphrey
                      -1968 campaign
                            -Allegation
                                  -Connally and contributions to the President
                 -Depletion
                      -President's position
                            -The President’s congressional experience
                      -Humphrey
                      -1969 action by President

Shultz, John D. Ehrlichman

The President’s instructions to Connally, Burns
                                               27

                            NIXON PRESIDENTIAL MATERIALS STAFF

                                       Tape Subject Log
                                         (rev. 10/06)
                                                                  Conv. No. 650-9 (cont.)



     President's schedule
          -Raymond K. Price, Jr.
                 -State of the Union address
                       -Draft
          -Burns

Burns and Connally left at 12:31 pm.